GAO urges Congress to let tribes initiate retrocession of state jurisdiction

Recommendation targets the roughly 65% of federally recognized tribes in states covered by Public Law 280, effective upon congressional action

Aerial view of the National Building Museum and surrounding Judiciary Square neighborhood in Washington, D.C.

The Government Accountability Office recommends that Congress amend Public Law 280 to authorize tribes to initiate retrocession of state criminal jurisdiction and to require tribal consent before a state can offer retrocession to the Secretary of the Interior. The recommendation would affect the roughly 65 percent of the 575 federally recognized tribes located in states named in the law.

Public Law 280, enacted in 1953, rescinded most federal criminal jurisdiction in Indian country for select states and granted concurrent jurisdiction to tribes and those states. Under current rules, a state may return its jurisdiction to the federal government without tribal initiation, and tribal consent is not required when a state initiates retrocession. GAO notes that this structure limits tribal self-determination.

GAO's analysis of Bureau of Indian Affairs funding data shows that, from fiscal years 2017 through 2021, tribes in Public Law 280 states received less funding per capita than tribes in other states. Tribal leaders interviewed said retrocession improves self-determination and eases coordination with state law enforcement, while state officials warned that losing access to state public-safety services could pose challenges.

The report examined statutes, federal memoranda, and crime and funding data for fiscal years 2017 through 2024, the most recent data available. GAO also interviewed officials from the BIA and DOJ, non-governmental stakeholders, legal scholars, tribal leaders, and state law-enforcement officials from three Public Law 280 states.

The GAO listed two open matters for congressional consideration: (1) amend the law to let tribes initiate retrocession and make federal criminal jurisdiction exclusive upon the Secretary's acceptance, and (2) require tribal consent for any state-offered retrocession. Agency responses to both matters remain pending.

Keep reading